Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Arco Aguas's avatar

This is fantastic. Having now read your first three newsletter publications, I really appreciate being able to follow the progression of your argument.

You began by identifying deceptive design, then examined the cognitive biases that make those practices effective, and here you move toward a structural intervention through Transparency by Design. I'm so excited to later get the chance to see how much more evolved your thought process has gotten, seeing as how this was all just the beginning of it, and I know for a fact you have defined yourself more.

What particularly vibed for me is your rejection of the assumption that users should arrive with specialized knowledge of the systems they interact with. The people designing and operating those environments possess information and control that ordinary users often do not, and that asymmetry carries responsibilities.

I appreciate your distinction between making a privacy option technically available and ensuring someone understands the consequences of exercising it.

There is also a tension between your second and third articles that I find fascinating. You previously explained how excessive information and choices can hinder decision-making. Here, you propose additional contextual disclosures and opportunities for informed selection. I think both arguments are valuable, and together they raise an important design challenge: how can transparency be implemented without creating another layer of cognitive overload or habituation to warnings?

The point that transparency does not necessarily establish meaningful control is still accurate today. Someone may fully understand what a platform intends to do with their information while lacking any practical alternative to accepting those conditions.

In my own work on AI governance, I've approached similar questions through the responsibilities of institutions that control the environments, capabilities, and conditions under which systems operate. While the subjects of protection differ, I see a meaningful connection in the need to make safeguards operational rather than merely declarative.

I've enjoyed following the development of your thinking through these early publications. Thank you for sharing not only the problems you've identified but also concrete proposals for addressing them.

Ready for more?