9 Comments
User's avatar
Ana Correa's avatar

I agree and I believe we need to have a realistic outlook like the one you point out: AI is here to stay. Based on that, I think it is urgent to participate in its design, development, and governance. Because of this in particular, I am modestly promoting the participation of more women with a critical perspective on development, so that AI doesn't become concentrated in the hands of those who push for its use in wars, for example. In September, a book of mine titled Ciberfeminismo, la hora de la acción (Cyberfeminism, the Hour for Action) will be released, in which I hope to modestly contribute to raising awareness about the importance of women's movements getting involved with a human rights perspective in these discussions. You are a great guide for that process. <3 (Ana Correa, from Argentina) https://www.linkedin.com/in/ana-correa-a82394a/

Hala Fawzi's avatar

As an EFL/ESL langugae educator, I am worried about the new forms of digital gaps AI is creating between native and non native English speakers.

State of Play's avatar

The post-AI utopia you're describing is already happening, just unevenly. Carrefour's data assistant now resolves customer support queries in about two minutes instead of hours, with three-quarters of tickets closed without a human touching them, across 700-800 staff. Nothing bigger than existing models made that possible; a curated data dictionary did. That's the pattern across the deployments that actually work: the technology stopped being the constraint years ago, and what predicts whether an organization gets there is whether it did the unglamorous documentation work first.

So the fight worth having isn't optimism versus skepticism as competing forecasts. It's whether the organizational capacity to reach that utopia gets built broadly, or stays concentrated in the handful of companies that already put in the groundwork.

Bruce Cohen's avatar

I’m a retired software engineer with some personal projects that require AI tools to develop. So I have a semi-optimistic view of AI as a tool and a technology. What I think makes the division between “doomers” and “accelerationists” greater is that very few people on either side understand the nature and limitations of the current technology. And very few people, outside of those affected, are aware of the current harms AI is inflicting.

Attending to the current harms of the use of AI might diminish the marketing chorus of cheerleaders while giving anti-AI people some sense of control over the trajectory of the changes it will bring in the future.

Mikko Tiihonen's avatar

As an entrepreneur working in the field of medical AI, my concern is that we will be regulating AI from a technology-centric perspective. This is unnecessary and potentially dangerous if regulation is written to enable any one technology. In healthcare, safety and reliability are non-negotiable, and those outcomes should be governed and enforced. Good regulation is technology-neutral. It should be based on abstract principles that protect people and serve the common good.

AJ MacNichol's avatar

I’m short the AI trade. So I’m looking forward to Mark Zuckerberg and Sam Altman being humbled 🙃

Tim Carswell's avatar

AI is a technology whose multitudinous applications across humanity cannot be categorised as good/optimistic or bad/pessimistic. It's like trying to determine whether electricity has been responsible for more good things than bad, it can clearly be used for either.