Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Arco Aguas's avatar

Luiza, I went back to your earlier work because I wanted to understand where your thinking began, and I found this particularly interesting.

What stands out to me is the distinction between giving someone choices and preserving their ability to exercise them meaningfully.

Your LinkedIn example illustrates this beautifully. A platform can technically provide extensive privacy controls while arranging them in a way that makes exercising those controls unnecessarily difficult. The existence of an option does not necessarily establish meaningful autonomy.

It also raises a broader question I've been examining in my own work on AI governance and asymmetric control: at what point does an environment's architecture become a mechanism of governance over those operating within it?

I also wonder whether the definition of deceptive design should depend on demonstrable manipulative intent, or whether a design's foreseeable consequences should be sufficient to trigger scrutiny. A system might consistently undermine meaningful choice through optimization, complexity, or institutional neglect, even where deliberate deception cannot be established.

That distinction seems particularly important when considering accountability. If the harm lies partly in the architecture itself, responsibility cannot always be evaluated solely through the intentions of individual designers.

I appreciate that you were examining these questions in 2022. The relationship between design, power, and meaningful consent has only become more consequential as our digital environments have evolved.

Ready for more?